Back to notes

Investing

Should You Invest or Pay Down Debt First? The Canadian Answer

Ashley PennellMay 7, 20265 min read

You have got $500 at the end of the month and two options: put it toward your mortgage or debt, or invest it. Which is the right move? Like most worthwhile financial questions, the honest answer is: it depends. But it depends on a few very specific things — and once you understand what those are, the answer becomes straightforward for your situation.

The Core Principle: Compare the After-Tax Rates

Paying down debt can reduce future interest costs, while investing creates an opportunity for returns and a risk of losses. The comparison depends on your borrowing rate, any prepayment charges, tax treatment, investment fees, timeline and need for accessible savings. Neither choice is automatically right for every household.

The key word is after-tax. Both the cost of debt and the return on investment need to be viewed on an after-tax basis to compare them fairly. This is where RRSP contributions change the calculation significantly.

When Paying Down Debt Wins

Prioritize debt repayment when the interest rate on your debt is high:

  • Credit cards at 19.99% to 29.99% — no investment reliably returns 20%+ annually. Paying this off is the highest-return "investment" you can make.
  • Personal loans and lines of credit at 8 to 15% — still difficult for most investment portfolios to consistently beat after fees and taxes.
  • Car loans at 6 to 10% — generally worth paying down aggressively before directing money toward investments.

The math is simple: if your debt costs you more than your investments earn, eliminating the debt first is the higher-return choice.

When Investing Wins: The RRSP Exception

The RRSP contribution changes this calculation for higher-income Canadians. Here is why:

For illustration, a deductible $10,000 RRSP contribution at a 40% marginal rate may reduce current tax by about $4,000. That is a tax deduction, not a 40% investment return or a guaranteed refund. Withdrawals are generally taxable, and your actual outcome depends on your income, deduction room, and tax situation.

The effective strategy: contribute to your RRSP to generate the refund, then use the refund to pay down debt. You get the tax advantage of the RRSP contribution and accelerate your debt repayment — a genuine win on both fronts.

The Mortgage Question: A Closer Look

For most Canadians, the biggest debt question is the mortgage. With current mortgage rates in the 4 to 6% range, the comparison becomes nuanced:

  • Mortgage interest is not tax-deductible for personal residences in Canada (unlike the US)
  • Mortgage prepayments can reduce interest costs; consider the mortgage terms, prepayment limits and any charges
  • Investment returns vary with the assets held, fees, taxes and market conditions. Diversification does not eliminate the possibility of loss
  • Check your actual TFSA and RRSP contribution room. Unused room can generally carry forward, but withdrawal and recontribution rules differ between account types

A reasonable approach for most Canadian homeowners: max TFSA and RRSP contributions first (the tax advantages are too valuable to leave unused), then direct any remaining surplus toward mortgage prepayments.

A Practical Framework by Debt Type

Debt Type Typical Rate Recommendation
Credit cards 20–30% Pay off immediately — always
Personal loans / LOC 8–15% Pay down aggressively before investing
Car loans 6–10% Pay down, then redirect to investments
Mortgage 4–6% Max RRSP/TFSA first, then prepay mortgage
Student loans (government) Prime rate Balance with TFSA investing — rates are low

The Right Answer Is Usually: Both

Very few Canadians should be doing exclusively one or the other. A balanced approach — directing some money toward high-interest debt elimination while simultaneously building investments inside a TFSA — is practical, psychologically sustainable, and financially sound for most households.

The specific split depends on your income, tax bracket, debt interest rates, and timeline. If you would like help working out the right balance for your situation, book a free call and we will run through the numbers together. Or send a message anytime.

Ashley Pennell

Ashley Pennell

Senior Financial Associate | Independent Broker
Experior Financial Group Inc.

Ashley is an independent broker based in Bowmanville, Ontario, helping individuals and families connect insurance, savings, and retirement decisions.

Learn about Ashley

Questions about your own situation?

Let’s take the time to talk it through.

Book a Conversation